Lake PoyganHomes for Sale

Lake Poygan Homes for Sale

Browse homes, cabins, cottages, and land for sale on Lake Poygan in Wisconsin.

Active
Listing picture for 9205 WILLOW LANE in Fremont
$999,999
5 bds | 3 ba | 3,420 sqft | 0.75 acres | singlefamily
9205 WILLOW LANE, Fremont - Town of WOLF RIVER
Active
Listing picture for 9512 LAURA LANE in Winneconne
$969,000
3 bds | 4 ba | 3,018 sqft | 0.46 acres | singlefamily
9512 LAURA LANE, Winneconne - Town of POYGAN
Active
Listing picture for COUNTY RD B in Winneconne
$629,000
bds | 0 ba | 0 sqft | 11.03 acres | land
COUNTY RD B, Winneconne - Town of POYGAN
Active
Listing picture for 8666 CTY RD B in Winneconne
$539,900
3 bds | 2 ba | 1,152 sqft | 1.52 acres | singlefamily
8666 CTY RD B, Winneconne - Town of POYGAN
Active
Listing picture for 7378 WIDGEON LANE in Larsen
$270,000
3 bds | 2 ba | 792 sqft | 0.27 acres | singlefamily
7378 WIDGEON LANE, Larsen - Town of WOLF RIVER
The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Wisconsin Real Estate Exchange. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal. Last Updated 08-05-2026 11:01:09 am
Rover IDX

Get New Lake Poygan Listings

The best lake properties sell fast. Get alerts when they list.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

About Lake Poygan

Lake Poygan is a popular, full-rec lake located in northeast Wisconsin. The lake is 14,102 acres in size with a maximum depth of 11 feet.

Poygan is known for its bustling waters, shallow depths, and wide variety of fish...including smallmouth bass and musky. It's also great for almost every type of water recreation, including jet skiing, water skiing, and speedboating.

Lake Poygan features three boat launches, making it easy for property owners to get their boats in and out each season. In addition, the lake is home to two restaurants you can boat to, two parks, and Lone Willow Island.

Lake Poygan's name comes from an Indigenous word meaning "pipe." Historical records show the lake appeared under several earlier names, including Lake Pwawgun and Pawacheguning Lake in 1839, followed by Lake Pahwaikan on original township survey plats published in 1852.

Tour Lake Poygan in Wisconsin

Lake Poygan Statistics

Lake Stats
Full Rec
Yes
Size
14102 acres
Ave Depth
7 feet
Max Depth
11 feet
Bottom Sand
30% sand
Water Clarity
2 feet
Shoreline
25 miles
Real Estate
Residential LotsLots zoned residential and not owned by a government body.
861
Vacant LotsResidential lots with less than $20k in assessed improvement value.
186 (22%)
Lots With HomesResidential lots with over $20k in assessed improvement value.
675 (78%)
Primary HomesResidential lots with homes and addresses that matches the mailing addresses of their owners.
321 (48%)
Vacation HomesResidential lots with homes and addresses that do not match the mailing addresses of their owners.
354 (52%)
Home TurnoverThis rate reflects MLS sales only. Many lake properties are sold off market.
17.4 (2.6%)
Ave Assess ValueThe average assessed value of lots on this lake with homes on them.
$406,335
Assessment RatioA state-calculated factor used to align assessed values across municipalities with different revaluation dates.
0.7645
Ave Fair MarketThe average assessed value of lots with homes divided by their muncipal assessment ratios.
$513,797
Total Fair MarketThe total fair market values of all lots on the lake.
$368,398,095
Fish Present
Bluegill
Bluegill Lake Fish
Yellow Perch
Yellow Perch Lake Fish
Black Crappie
Black Crappie Lake Fish
Smallmouth Bass
Smallmouth Bass Lake Fish
Largemouth Bass
Largemouth Bass Lake Fish
Walleye
Walleye Lake Fish
Northern Pike
Northern Pike Lake Fish
Musky
Musky Lake Fish

Lake Poygan Market Report

The statistics below compare the past 12 months of home sales to the lake's 5-year average.

Market Summary

  • Market vs Tax: Prices are up 63.1% ▲ vs assessed.
  • Price Trend: Recent sale prices are up 30.3% ▲.
  • Negotiation: Sales at 95.1% of list (down 2.3% ▼).
  • Inventory: New listings are up 1.9% ▲.
  • Sales Volume: Number of sales is down 31% ▼.
  • Speed: Days on market (DOM) is down 2.9% ▼.

Average Annual Sold Prices

Past 12-Mo
$663k
Past 5-Yr
$509k

Lake Poygan vs Nearby Lakes

Lake
12-Mo
Listed
12-Mo
Sold
12-Mo
List $
12-Mo
Sold $
12-Mo
DOM
5-Year
Listed
5-Year
Sold
5-Year
List $
5-Year
Sold $
5-Year
DOM
Lake PoyganPoygan
21
12
$697k
$663k
68
103
87
$523k
$509k
70
Lake WinneconneWinneconne
14
12
$714k
$680k
81
53
43
$575k
$566k
73
Lake Butte des MortsButte des Morts
46
41
$545k
$530k
87
175
149
$564k
$545k
86
Silver LakeSilver
6
5
$1,275k
$1,230k
94
34
30
$894k
$882k
69
Chain O'LakesChain O'Lakes
23
9
$1,878k
$1,885k
77
64
49
$1,299k
$1,248k
139

Next 12 Month Sales Forecast

21
Homes
Listed
19
Homes
Sold

What’s Your Lake Home Worth?

Thinking of selling? Find out your lake home’s current market value.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Photo of Lake Poygan in Wisconsin by Penny Gonzales
    Photo by Penny Gonzales
  • Photo of Lake Poygan in Wisconsin by Ken Wilson
    Photo by Ken Wilson
  • Photo of Lake Poygan in Wisconsin by Donna Puls 
    Photo by Donna Puls 
  • Photo of Lake Poygan in Wisconsin by Barb Miller
    Photo by Barb Miller
  • Photo of Lake Poygan in Wisconsin by Amy Erdmann
    Photo by Amy Erdmann
  • Default Alt Text
Get Involved 3 329x329 1

Boom Bay Heights Improvement Association
Ray Meyer
bbhiaboombay@​yahoo.com

For assistance contact:

Dmitri Martin
Lake Poygan Specialist
Rustic Waters Realty

Dmitri Martin Profile Photo

Source of Data: Wisconsin Real Estate Exchange (WIREX). Disclaimer of Use: Information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Disclaimer of Data: Information received from other 3rd parties: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal. Neither listing broker nor Rustic Waters Realty LLC nor WIREX shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Copyright: ® 2024 WIREX – All Rights Reserved. Last Updated: 8/5/26